Women in combat: Will they have to register for the draft? - Yahoo! News (Legal answer is yes)

Women in combat: Will they have to register for the draft? - Yahoo! News (Legal answer is yes)

Deal Price: News
yahoo.com offers Women in combat: Will they have to register for the draft? - Yahoo! News (Legal answer is yes) for News.
Now that the Pentagon is lifting its ban on women in combat, does this mean that women could potentially be drafted, too?
And as a practical matter: When women turn 18, will they now need to register, as men do, so that they can be conscripted in the event of a World War III, or any military emergency where the US government decides it needs troops quickly?
It’s a thorny question, raising what may be a difficult prospect societally. But the legal implications are obvious, analysts argue.

“The answer to that question is clearly yes,” says Anne Coughlin, a law professor at the University of Virginia School of Law in Charlottesville. “The legal argument is clear: If it comes to that kind of wrenching emergency where we have to press young people into service, there is no legal justification for saying that men alone need to shoulder that burden.”
The wars of the past decade in Iraq and Afghanistan have been fought by an all-volunteer force, since the US military discontinued the draft in 1973. Males between the ages of 18 and 25, however, are still required to register for the Selective Service.
Once the combat exclusion policy is lifted, “My belief is that if we open up combat arms to women, even on a voluntary basis, if there is a draft, we should be able to force women into those positions,” says retired Col. Peter Mansoor, a professor of military history at the Ohio State University in Columbus and a former US Army brigade commander who served two tours in Iraq.

“If women are acceptable to serve in combat, they are acceptable to serve whether they volunteer or not. You can’t have the frosting on the cake and not the cake underneath,” he says.
Legal precedent backs this up, adds Professor Coughlin, who has advised plaintiffs in lawsuits to overturn the Pentagon’s combat exclusion policy – in particular a US Supreme Court case in 1981, Rostker v. Goldberg. In that suit, men argued that the draft is unconstitutional because only men are required by law to register. The Supreme Court rejected the premise of lawsuit.
“The court ruled that the Selective Service process is designed to assemble combat-ready people, and right now women are excluded from combat arms,” Coughlin says. “Therefore they can’t participate in the very thing that the draft is for. Hence, it’s appropriate and constitutional to continue to exclude women from the draft.”
Yet in overturning combat exclusion for women, “The male-only draft falls as well, no question about it,” she adds.
Critics of women in combat argue that culturally, the prospect of women being drafted might make the country reluctant to go to war.
To that, Professor Mansoor says, “It should be: That’s exactly the debate the country needs to have.”
But while the notion of women being drafted “may add some measure of hesitancy to the decision, I don’t see it as swinging the decision,” he says.
Even so, “Congress and the president should agonize over going to war. Questions of war should be difficult,” Mansoor adds. “They should not be as easy as they’ve been in the past 10 years.”
Deal or No Deal?
0   0

(1) thoughts from other users ...

solowkoe
rep: 5.52k
I heard about this on the radio. I thinks its cool. thanks for sharing.
solowkoe posted Jan 24, 2013
  0 |   0
Email to a friend
Facebook Share
Twitter

news deals

Bella Sport Rocket Blender in Red or Turquoise $5.99...
Bella Sport Rocket Blender in Red or...
News (4 plusses)
Toys R Us In Store Clearance Savings - Save Upto 60%...
Toys R Us In Store Clearance Savings - Save...
News (4 plusses)
Taco Bell to test fast-casual restaurant
Taco Bell to test fast-casual restaurant
News (4 plusses)
15 Revealing Signs You Genuinely Love What You Do
15 Revealing Signs You Genuinely Love What...
News (4 plusses)
Customize Your Android Notification Bar with These 3...
Customize Your Android Notification Bar with...
News (4 plusses)
Apple’s next big thing is already here – and...
Apple’s next big thing is already here –...
News (4 plusses)
AOL Launching Free Streaming Movies Service With...
AOL Launching Free Streaming Movies Service...
News (5 plusses)
Staples Weekly Coupons | 4/27 - 5/3
Staples Weekly Coupons | 4/27 - 5/3
News (10 plusses)
Send a $5 gift to a friend via Facebook and get a FREE...
Send a $5 gift to a friend via Facebook and...
News (5 plusses)
12oz Freshly Squeezed Juice for $2
12oz Freshly Squeezed Juice for $2
COUPON (14 plusses)
iOS 7.1.1 brings huge battery life improvements for...
iOS 7.1.1 brings huge battery life...
News (4 plusses)
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant | $10 Bonus Card with...
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant | $10 Bonus...
$10 GC (5 plusses)
Macy's Friends and Family 25% off April 29th - May 5th
Macy's Friends and Family 25% off April 29th...
News (4 plusses)
Preview May’s Instant Game Collection –...
Preview May’s Instant Game Collection –...
News (5 plusses)
Staples Weekly Ad (Apr 27 - May 3)
Staples Weekly Ad (Apr 27 - May 3)
News (5 plusses)
$1.50 off Silk® Protein + Fiber Coupon!
$1.50 off Silk® Protein + Fiber Coupon!
Coupon! (5 plusses)
FCC approves T-Mobile acquisition of Verizon's A-block...
FCC approves T-Mobile acquisition of...
News (5 plusses)
Hacker-turned-FBI informant may have orchestrated...
Hacker-turned-FBI informant may have...
News (5 plusses)
New Target Mobile Coupons l 4/24
New Target Mobile Coupons l 4/24
Coupons! (7 plusses)
NFL Football Jersey’s on sale for only $10.00
NFL Football Jersey’s on sale for only...
News (15 plusses)
Apple may launch updated MacBook Airs as soon as next...
Apple may launch updated MacBook Airs as...
News (4 plusses)
Big Lots Weekly Ad | 4/26 - 5/4
Big Lots Weekly Ad | 4/26 - 5/4
News (6 plusses)
'GMA' Mega Deals and Steals: Spring Fling! - Yahoo
'GMA' Mega Deals and Steals: Spring Fling! -...
News (4 plusses)
One Thing You Should Know about Your iPhone if You...
One Thing You Should Know about Your iPhone...
News (4 plusses)
Here’s how a 4.7-inch iPhone 6 would stack up...
Here’s how a 4.7-inch iPhone 6 would stack...
News (4 plusses)
Einstein Bros : BOGO Free Applewood Bacon & Cheddar...
Einstein Bros : BOGO Free Applewood Bacon &...
BOGO (5 plusses)
DSW : $5 Bonus Card for Every $50 Gift Cards
DSW : $5 Bonus Card for Every $50 Gift Cards
$5 GC (5 plusses)
B1 Get 2nd For $1 For All Family Shoes at Kmart
B1 Get 2nd For $1 For All Family Shoes at...
News (4 plusses)
Yankee Stadium Tour with Optional Lunch for Two or...
Yankee Stadium Tour with Optional Lunch for...
News (4 plusses)
Social - Macy's- Mothers Day Gifts
Social - Macy's- Mothers Day Gifts
News (4 plusses)